Discovering Anthony's at Sea Isle City: A Coastal Culinary Gem
Nestled along the vibrant coastline of New Jersey, Anthony's at Sea Isle City stands as a cherished landmark for both long-time residents and seasonal visitors seeking an authentic taste of the shore. Located prominently at 8600 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243, United States, this establishment has cultivated a reputation that extends far beyond its physical address. It represents more than just a place to dine; it embodies the relaxed, yet refined, spirit of a classic Jersey Shore experience. The atmosphere seamlessly blends casual comfort with high-quality service, making it an ideal destination for everything from a spontaneous lunch after a day on the beach to a memorable evening celebration.
The enduring appeal of Anthony's lies in its commitment to freshness and its deep connection to the surrounding maritime environment. While the specific offerings evolve with the seasons, the core philosophy remains steadfast: to present the best of the Atlantic in a welcoming setting. Patrons often describe the experience as feeling like a true local secret, even though its popularity is well-known. This balance—between being accessible and maintaining a distinct, high-caliber identity—is what keeps diners returning year after year, often marking their summer calendars around their next visit to this iconic location.
Exploring the culinary landscape of the Jersey Shore requires an appreciation for seafood prepared with respect and creativity. Anthony's has mastered this delicate balance, offering dishes that honor traditional preparations while occasionally introducing contemporary flair. The location itself, situated right on Landis Avenue, positions it perfectly to capture the energy of Sea Isle City, offering views and an ambiance that truly define the shore experience. It’s a place where the sound of the ocean often mingles pleasantly with the convivial buzz of happy diners.
Key Highlights of the Anthony's Experience
What sets Anthony's apart in the competitive dining scene of the New Jersey coast? Several defining characteristics contribute to its sustained success and positive reputation among food enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
Commitment to Fresh, Local Sourcing: The menu places a significant emphasis on ingredients sourced as locally as possible, particularly seafood. This dedication ensures that the flavors presented are vibrant and reflective of the region’s bounty. Diners can often taste the difference that proximity to the source makes in every bite, whether it’s a simple steamed delicacy or a complex entrée.
Atmosphere Reflecting Coastal Charm: The interior design and overall ambiance successfully capture the essence of Sea Isle City. It manages to feel upscale enough for a special occasion without ever feeling stuffy or overly formal. This approachable elegance makes it suitable for families, couples, and groups of friends looking for quality dining in a relaxed environment.
Versatile Dining Options: Anthony's caters to various dining preferences throughout the day. Whether one is looking for a light appetizer and a refreshing beverage during the afternoon sun or a full, multi-course dinner experience as the evening cools, the structure of the restaurant supports diverse needs. This flexibility is crucial for a destination spot that sees high traffic across different times and occasions.
Prime Location on Landis Avenue: Situated at 8600 Landis Ave, the restaurant benefits from excellent visibility and accessibility within the heart of Sea Isle City. This central positioning makes it an easy stop for those exploring the boardwalk, the beaches, or the town’s main thoroughfare, cementing its role as a central gathering point.
These elements combine to create a dining destination that is both reliable and exciting. It’s the kind of establishment where memories are made, often becoming an annual tradition for many who vacation or reside nearby. The focus remains squarely on delivering a superior product within an environment that celebrates the unique spirit of Sea Isle City.
Concluding Thoughts on a Shore Staple
Anthony's at Sea Isle City is more than just a restaurant; it is an integral part of the local fabric, offering a consistent standard of quality that patrons have come to rely upon. For anyone visiting the southern New Jersey coast, particularly those exploring the charm of Sea Isle City, a stop at 8600 Landis Ave is highly recommended. It offers a genuine slice of coastal dining excellence, rooted in fresh ingredients and a welcoming, seaside atmosphere. The enduring legacy of Anthony's is built upon these simple yet profound commitments to quality and community, ensuring its place as a premier dining choice for years to come.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Outdoor seating
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Great wine list
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Wine
Dining options
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar on site
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
High chairs
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Paid street parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews Anthonys Sea Isle City
beshsy2k2
08-12-2025
Have been going here for years and never had an experience like I did on Monday night. We sat down in the ballroom section of the restaurant because we were a party of 12. The waitress was very attentive throughout the night. Once they took our food order, then things went south. Our appetizers came out 1-2 at a time, so family members were done with theirs before others got theirs. It was the same thing with entrees, but WORSE! Not all the food came out at the same time , and my cousin didn’t get her meal! They said 2-3 times that it was on its way, and it never came. On top of that, no one at the table got theirs sides that came with the entree. Was brought to their attention , and nothing happened. Was told by our waitress that the manager would personally bring out my cousins meal, and he never showed his up. Finally we got the last meal; but asked for it to go because the other 11 people were done with their food. The entree that never came was gnocchi with meatballs! Why was that taking so long. Our entrees were fantastic, tasted great, but didn’t get our sides. The poor waitress was overworked/overwhelmed, and didn’t get the support from her manager OR the kitchen staff. It’s really a shame, because we have never had an experience like this. Our bill was over $600 and no one got their entire meal.
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 4
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Group size
9+ people
Wait time
No wait
Pat McCann
05-12-2025
Incredibly mid, not worth the price. Food was bland and drowned in sauce and the drinks were sub-par. Do yourself a favor and grab a bottle of wine and go across the street to Sole More
Lindsay Callantine
04-12-2025
First time here since it switched over from the previous tenant. We sat at the bar. Food was great, bar tender (Lauren I think?) was super friendly and always available. No complaints at all! Will definitely be back and recommend to others! We came on a slow night but I can see how reservations are recommended. And the bar filled up quickly after 6:30 so plan ahead!
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Wait time
No wait
susan
23-10-2025
First time and likely the last time. We had a reservation on a Friday night and were sat promptly in the far back room. Seating is tight and the noise level was off the charts. It made it impossible to converse with table mates. I ordered the meatballs with gnocchi and asked for capellini instead and I am not exaggerating, they served 2 meatballs and no less than 2 lbs of pasta with a very bland sauce, aka gravy, in a large bowl. It was ridiculous! Really, only 2 meatballs with all that pasta?? My friends had the veal Oscar, veal Parmesan and eggplant Parmesan which they all said were good.
The waitress was friendly and attentive but the servers were always at the table looking to clear plates while folks were still eating. Pet peeve…Felt like we were being a bit rushed.
Overall, for what we spent, there are other options where we can go enjoy a more relaxed and comfortable meal and also be able to have an enjoyable conversation.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 1
tom jen
18-10-2025
Went in underdressed, sat at the bar for a few drinks.
I was treated no differently than everyone else there, and the tequila sunrise … More
Bri O'Meara
25-09-2025
We were really excited to go here during our trip. They were able to hold our wine for us while we went to grab a drink elsewhere before our reservation which was great. The hostess was attentive and uncorked our wine as soon as we were … More
Julieann Baranowski
02-09-2025
We just had dinner during Memorial Day weekend. The kitchen staff was not prepared for the crowd. We ordered the eggplant parmesan and unfortunately the sauce was tasteless. We had to add a lot of salt and pepper, it tasted like mass … More
Cecil Locatelli
28-08-2025
Miss my favorite
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Best clams casino, basked clams and bruschetta ever
Price per pe…
More
Dale Polhemus
20-08-2025
We dined outside on sidewalk tables, ok but not as nice as indoor, which had no availability. It's also BYOB, but if you forget, you can call , they deliver. We did that, and the bottle of wine arrived within 10 minutes. The food was good … More
Pat Rombola
15-08-2025
Beautiful restaurant! Our server Justin was excellent, very attentive and knowledgeable! Food was delicious . Highly recommend Chicken Parmigiana, Crab stuffed shrimp, or if available, the Halibut! More
Dalton Eggles
08-08-2025
Putting this first as a PSA: Don’t bother if you have any type of dietary restriction or food allergy. When we had made the reservation, we were assured there would be an option for one of the members of our group; unfortunately that wasn’t the case, and they failed to accommodate.
As for the food… Considering they advertise as a nicer Italian restaurant I was disappointed. The food was just okay and honestly on par with store bought.
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 3
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Group size
3-4 people
Dietary restrictions
They couldn’t accommodate even though they said they could when the reservation was made.
Parking space
Somewhat difficult to find parking
Wheelchair accessibility
There is an elevator to take you to the dining room/bar
Craig Felker
04-08-2025
Crab cakes were extremely disappointing. You spend $38, you ought to have lump crab. Instead, the crabmeat was shredded and didn't have much flavor. … More
Jim Davis
27-07-2025
We sat outside, so I can't comment on the indoor ambiance or atmosphere. I got the crab cakes which were very generously sized and excellent. The lobster bisque was excellent as well, although it was a special and not a regular menu item. Reasonably priced for a nice restaurant at the store. Five stars! More
Tara Amoroso
18-07-2025
We had an unfortunate dinner at Anthony‘s tonight. My lemon drop martini came out with a salted rim instead of sugar rim two times before the bartender got it right. Additionally, three of our pasta dishes were incorrect in that they put … More
Stephanie Valleras
27-06-2025
We couldn’t have picked a better venue for our wedding! The space was absolutely perfect — beautiful, comfortable, and such a great atmosphere for our guests. The team was so helpful throughout the entire planning process and made everything feel easy and stress-free.
The food was incredible (we’re still getting compliments from guests weeks later!), and the staff went above and beyond to make sure the night ran smoothly. One of the best parts was how they handled cleanup — we didn’t have to worry about gathering all our things at the end of the night, which made it so nice to just enjoy the evening.
We’re so grateful for the amazing experience and couldn’t recommend this venue more!
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
JOJODEALIO FILMS
24-05-2025
Never had a bad meal here. I also visit the Delaware county location which is also a great restaurant. Our server was Janelle who was exceptional. She was always smiling and on top of everything. We would ask for her at her old … More
gregory guarini
18-05-2025
Me and my Wife have gone to Anthony’s at least 5 or 6 times since the spring. We love the food and atmosphere. The service was excellent. We’ve eaten at the bar and also sat in the dining room. More
Diane Claffey
15-05-2025
We had a wonderful experience for dinner! The hostess, Meredith was very accommodating! Billy, our waiter was very nice and prompt considering how busy he was with many tables. The food was delicious. The portions were plentiful. More
Will Helms
07-05-2025
The one hostess is the best. She needs a raise. Great chicken Stephen
Food: 5…
More
Sam T
09-04-2025
Our first time here and we'll definitely be back! The veal parm was perfectly crispy and the sauce of the Chicken Stephen was very tasty. Everyone was friendly and the bright decor is inviting.
Frank Davis
09-04-2025
Food was exceptional. Baked clams were very good. Great for dipping your bread into at the end. Veal Sinatra is outstanding. Has an elevator for those who need one. More
Steve Malloy
08-04-2025
Feedback is the breakfast of champions, right? After years of disappointment with the previous attempts at this venue, I had high hopes that new ownership would DRAMATICALLY improve the food and service at the venue on Landis Ave. It’s … More
JD Doemling
06-04-2025
The service was top-notch, but what really stood out was the incredible hospitality from the manager, Connor. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect—from checking in on our table personally to handling a minor request with professionalism and a genuine smile. You can tell he takes real pride in what he does and cares about the guest experience. The food was great, but the service made the night. Thanks, Connor—we’ll definitely be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Nick Boxter
04-04-2025
Good food a a bunch local beers available. Bartenders are hustlers, always quick and attentive service despite being slammed with people. Be careful the espresso martinis will get you hooked for life!
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Loud, but you can still talk
Wait time
10-30 min
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Bar area, Booth seating, Counter seating, Private dining room
Wheelchair accessibility
On 2nd floor but there is an elevator
Michael DuBick
03-04-2025
Among the best restaurants in Cape May County on the Jersey shore. The inside dining area is comfortable and nicely decorated. The noise level is correct and allows for comfortable conversation. The wait staff is highly professional. … More
David Martino
03-04-2025
What a fantastic place... Everything was awesome the food was awesome and everything was delicious! The people there were unbelievable lyrics friendly and cheerful. The entire experience was just better than perfect! Highly recommend for everyone, course, groups and even take out.
Kyle
01-04-2025
If you don't want to read all of this I'll understand, so quick snapshot: DO. NOT. EAT. HERE. … More
Patti Williamson
22-03-2025
Enjoyed our meals at Anthony’s. Service was perfectly timed. The meatball appetizer was huge and so tasty.. it could be a meal. The specialty veal dishes were amazing. We had Veal Saltimbocca and Veal Anthony. The Madeira sauce with the … More
Marc Holmes
25-02-2025
It was ... Okay. The food seemed to be uninspired. The clam chowder was too salty, the meatball was a little mushy, the stuffed artichokes could have done without the crab, the scallops on the appetizer were not attractive but tasted okay … More
Louis Lenchner
22-02-2025
Just treated my wife for her birthday there and we really LOVED their food there! Want to give you shout out to our waiter, Billy who was great! The vibe, atmosphere, staff, the food, etc. For those who want to celebrate and are around South Jersey shore area, this is the place to be. Highly recommend this place!
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
Wait time
No wait
Linda Hannigan
22-02-2025
Loved Anthony's first location. Tonight was our first time at the new location. It's lovely. I was looking forward to my dinner. Server was stressed out. Apps were good. Love the tomatoes with crab & lobster sauce. Fig & arugula salad … More
Tiffany Kendorski
21-02-2025
Food was not good! I actually felt nauseous from eating the food. Was an hour wait to be seated. Waitress was friendly and apologized but overall would not recommend as so many nice BYOBs on the Island and this restaurant just doesn’t compare. Not worth the time and money at all. More
Nicole Kane
14-02-2025
My family and I went to Anthony’s on Monday evening for some drinks. The new spot is beautiful and is a bit of a drive from the center of town where we rent. Our bartender Corinne was professional, fun, and engaging. She was well versed in … More
Jimmy Contreras
02-02-2025
Nice ambiance, definitely a little more luxury than anticipated in Sea Isle City. The service wasn’t great but good. Ava, our waitress seemed a bit overwhelmed. The food was amazing! I was pleasantly surprised. I ordered a special salad of … More
Joe Casalena
24-01-2025
Been a customer for several years when they were located in the center of sic. Yesterday i decided to drive from Avalon to take my 88 year old aunt to dinner who lives in Philadelphia. I mad a reservation 4 hours ahead of time and ask for … More
S B
14-01-2025
The food is pretty bad, despite the fun atmosphere. It's like everyone in the dining room is so happy to be down the shore with friends and family... we're all pretending that the food is amazing. It's not. This place is weirdly fancy for … More
Lorraine Rogers
06-01-2025
Just got my to go order from Anthony's and it was horrible. I'm a long time customer from when they were on 44th Street and always looked forward to getting their food multiple times throughout the summer. I ordered 3 basic meals ( 2 … More
Noel Abejo
05-01-2025
Great location at the heart of Sea Isle. Excellent service and plenty to choose from. Had the lobster bisque soup and sea bass for main course. The Branzino was also cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside and it was tender. More
Meredith Warren
03-01-2025
Got seated immediately as a party of 6 with no reservation. Our server , maybe her name was Layla, was wonderful. She was personable, knowledgeable about the menu and so kind to our kids. We loved the beet salad, egg plant appetizer, crab risotto special, veal parm, crab cake and all of our items. Nice selection of wines and a full bar too.
Very pleased with our first visit here.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Barbara Dafter
24-12-2024
We went there tonight for dinner. The drinks were delicious. The food was outstanding. We both had the Chicken Stephen. I cannot say enough good things about this entree. The Gran Mariner cream sauce on this entree of chicken & shrimp … More
Reviews Anthonys Sea Isle City